Sunday, March 1, 2009

Thoughts on pricing discipline in must-have cars

How much did you pay for your car?

If you bought it new, I guarantee the price you paid was not the one on the sticker.

In 1985, Saturn Motors Corporation, a mostly autonomous division of General Motors introduced a new kind of automotive experience. Some of the tenets of Saturn's brand launch were:

- an easily changeable body shape due to plastic body panels,
- a company owned dealership where every buyer was cheered when he bought a car
- a single factory where people could visit and tour if they were customers
- an annual summer picnic for all owners, and
- fixed price (aka "no-haggle" pricing)

This last one is the subject of tonight's blog.

Why is it that you pay a SINGLE, sticker-advertised, fixed price for an ipod at the Apple Store or a used car at CarMax, but with new cars it is always negotiable?



People have answered this question with varying reasons for years, but my opinion is that "competition between sellers" is the reason why new car prices are negotiable.

Dealers compete to get your business. Period.

MSRP - Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price - is just that..... Suggested. With scarce, popular cars, pricing of a model may seem like a unified front, but even in those cases, you can usually look far and wide enough and find a dealer willing to do better than another in order to get your business.


Dealers compete to get your business. Period.

This is why Saturn had it right. Own the dealerships and set the price.

Sounds easy right? Well, it is really, except for the capital and people necessary to "own" all of those dealerships. All that stuff costs time and money; so if you need to grow fast in order to support the scale of your operations, then you need to find a way to enlist huge amounts of help. That is why franchises can work so well. They encourage a person to share in the growth of a business in return for that franchisee taking the risk to set up a branded dealership. But given a choice wherein I could grow a business profitably in doing so, I would always choose to own my own path to market as a business because you can protect the product, the brand and the profit margin much better.

Time for a real life example.


A friend of mine from California recently bought a new Audi. She was deeply excited about the new S5 (see above), and wanted one badly....Can't say I blame her, right? This is a sexy coupe compared to the competition. She asked for my help - as many of my car-buying friends have lately - in finding a way to get the best deal. I gave her some tips and even introduced her to some folks whom I thought could help her. For the first week of calling around, she got the same answer that this "exciting car could be had for MSRP". But with just a little bit of stick-to-it-iveness, she began to uncover some deals, which then lead to more deals, and before long, dealers who had earlier quoted her MSRP as "their final offer" were now willing to go as low as anyone else to get her business. After the purchase (at a significant discount to MSRP), I called her to ask one key question: "If every dealer had quoted you MSRP, without a discount, would you have bought the same car?" And she said, without much thought.....


All that time and effort that Audi took to make the S5 a must-have product for my friend, and then the dealers collectively stole it away. There is a valuable piece of profit that Audi will never see again.

The moral of the story: Make a must-have product then price with discipline.


Fangyaya said...

jordan 11
ray bans
ray ban outlet
cartier watches outlet
cheap rolex watches
louis vuitton outlet
air jordan shoes
oakley vault
designer handbags
nfl jerseys wholesale
celine outlet
coach outlet store online clearances
ralph lauren polo shirts
ralph lauren clearance outlet
michael kors outlet online
coach outlet
coach outlet canada
louis vuitton
lebron 13
louis vuitton outlet
true religion outlet
hermes bags
louis vuitton outlet
cheap jordans
adidas stan smith
kate spade outlet
adidas yeezy
ray ban outlet
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet
toms wedges
louboutin femme
coach factory outlet
cheap oakleys
air jordan 8
adidas trainers
montblanc pen
louis vuitton bags

Unknown said...

nike air force
true religion sale
omega replica watches
moncler outlet store
true religion outlet store
ralph lauren outlet
uggs outlet
kd shoes
mlb jerseys free shipping
babyliss hair dryer
true religion outlet
black timberland boots
mizuno running shoes
rolex replica watches
oakley vault outlet store
nike free flyknit 5.0
nhl jerseys wholesale
sac longchamp
vans outlet store
versace sunglasses wholesale
hollister clothing store
yeezy boost 350 balck
kobe bryant shoes
cheap rolex replica watches
cheap ugg boots
true religion jeans
michael kors uk
louis vuitton outlet
tiffany and co outlet
michael kors canada
polo ralph lauren outlet online
louboutin pas cher
oakley sunglasses cheap
the north face outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet

Unknown said...

kate spade outlet

nba jerseys
jordan 8
true religion
canada goose outlet
fitflops clearance
christian louboutin
ralph lauren polo
mbt shoes

Rebecca Virginia said...

Thanks for Sharing. Complete Your Dissertation From Dissertation writers UK and Score Best Result. said...

Bangladesh Education Result Board & Government Official website. HSC Admission Result 2020 Recently Published. Government web. HSC Result Student can download HSC Admission Result PDF File.

jasonbob said...

supreme t shirt
giannis shoes
kevin durant shoes
pg shoes
golden goose
golden goose
lebron 16
golden goose starter
kd 13

yanmaneee said...

kd 12
yeezy supply
longchamp handbags
lebron 18
air jordan
curry 6
nike sb said...

Govt School Admission Lottery Result 2021 recently published. Student or Candidate first & easily apply this school admission lottery result. Government web: Govt School Admission Lottery Result . said...

Ideal School and College Admission Circular recently published. Student or Candidate first & easily apply this ideal school and college admission. Government Personal Official website Link: Ideal School and College Admission Circular . said...

Primary Teacher Admit Card has been published. Our Government official website. Primary Admit Card said...

Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSC Result 2021) Published on our Government official website : HSC Result 2021 Student can download HSC Routine PDF File.

jafor said...

Hi Daer, Good Article and Design
Very Good Website and also Very Good Content. I've please to see the comment option of your Website which allow taking a backlink quickly. Thank you.

Also Check said...

GST Admission Result 2021 Recently published. Government web:
GST Admission Result Student can download Admission Result PDF File.

Unknown said...

Get all Bangladesh education board result, Exam Routine, National University Result, HSC Result 2021, Alim Result 2021, JSC result 2021, HSC Admission Result, University Admission Circular, IPO Result 2021, Government Job in Bangladesh, and education news from our Government official website: Student or Candidate first & easily online University admission, Admit Card download, admission result, apply & download from our official website.

Unknown said...

Bangladesh Bangladesh Public Service’s Authority Published The . Candidate can download BCS Examination Result and 20 Universities Integrated Admission Result or Result has been published.
Bangladesh Public Service’s Authority Published The

yanmaneee said...

lebron 17 shoes
off white
jordan sneakers
yeezy boost 350
golden goose
paul george shoes
air jordan
off white nike
nike dunks
kd 12 said...

Getting your GST Result 2021 is very easy. To get your result is easily and quickly, it will be better for you to visit the official website. We are also here to help you with Guccho Admission Result please visit our website. said...

NID Card Online Copy Download 2021: Those who for NID Ctard Application but have not received NID Card now. They can visit the Bangladesh Election Commission Office through download National Identity Card (NID) collect template use. Also our website method you know every process. so folow to our website.

bamgosoocom said...

Nice post. I learn something new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon everyday. It will always be useful to read content from other authors and use something from other websites.

(jk) said...

National University from all students protection has been published by the NU authority. students can (Covid-19) Vaccine Registration online as well our website - every information found.

All Education Result said...

20 General Science and Technology University is published the gst admission selection result 2021 on result page. students just need roll number to check the result.

check Also:
1. gst university admit card download
2. guccho university result
3. gst selection result
4. gst preliminary result

Ordain IT said...

Thank you for helping people get the information they need. Great stuff as usual. Keep up the great work!!!

the news said...

Robert shumake >> Detroit’s homeless treated to Red Carpet luncheon
Robert shumake

All New Result said...

The ministry of education is published the gsa result 2022 for
all government school on gsa result teletalk com bd official
website. is an extensive educatinal portal where you can find admission, board, job and any exam result.

All New Result said...

Government School Admission (GSA) Authority is published the class 1-9 admission result based on lottery on result as well as exam result hub educational portal.

Ordain IT said...

Ordain IT Provides Various design services. Like UI/UX design, graphics design

Anonymous said...

Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2 Full Movie
Sarkaru Vaari Paata Full Movie
Bachchan Pandey Full Movie
Bigg Boss 16 Live
Bigg Boss 16 Online

KeiraDoltan said...

This article is quite interesting and I am looking forward to reading more of your posts. Thanks for sharing this article with us.
Online Essay Writing Help

brady said...

I am glad to read this article

JNU Admission Test Result

Movies said...

Brahmastra Full Movie

whoosit said...

look here Discover More Here click resources about his More Help replica ysl

mama karo said...

has provided many benefits to members by giving lots of bonuses that are abundant with a minimum of 10k more info