Thursday, May 1, 2008

Is "Listening to The Community" Stagnating Design?

A couple of days ago, an LM community member (and fantastic designer) posed the challenge:

"by aiming for design democracy, I feel [Local Motors is] not actually advancing design, but rather stagnating it a bit by giving power to the people"

Could it be?!?!

Are we killing the advancement of design?

I would pose another 2 questions.

1) What is the advancement of design?

A) Is it actually building cars that otherwise would never be built? or

B) Is it designing cars that are so far out that they will never be built?

2) Are we really democratizing design?

To answer question 1) I would point to a design like the Guggenheim museum in Bilbao, Spain. If that opus were never built, would it have done as much to advance design? I think the answer must be no. To me, this says that building a design is an incredibly important part of advancing it for all generations of artists and onlookers. It really does not matter whether you like this particular building or another, the question is what benefit does building a design in reality make?





(www.ehu.es)


To answer question 2) I would ask "if people cannot share their voice about design, then how can designers improve?" It is not true that Local Motors let's the raw democracy choose a winner. LM reserves the right to choose any winner(s) at any time, but we listen carefully to the comments and votes of the others who take their time to come to the site. We would be silly not to. They (and their comments) are also one of the most exciting forms of feedback for the designers in the community. Those designers can choose to ignore those comments, but they do so at their own peril. In the end, if a designer is lucky, real people will end up buying a design if it is built, and it is incredibly valuable to hear what those buyers/users might think early on in the design process. No one is saying the designer HAS to listen to them...but wouldn't you? After all, it was not a single person, but rather a group of people that chose Gehry to design the museum in Bilbao.

Only time, will really tell if we at LM have stagnated transportation design, but I think the early indications are exactly the opposite, we are allowing it to sprint forward at warp speed....Fun to think about, and thank you for the challenge.

11 comments:

Robin Spinks said...

No - listening gives you more options from which to choose. Because the concept of Local Motors does not require huge infrastructure around any one design, you can take more risk with design. You can present options to the buying public and get quicker feedback from the market on which designs they like. That's the democracy -the market. As the executives of LM, you still have to make the final choice for the design - no matter how much input you have from the design community. As executives, you are still a dictator - well-informed and persuaded, maybe, but still you have to choose.

Yoav said...

Very thought-provoking, this one.

There are points along the spectrum between the current situation (very few designers, very few companies making cars one can buy) and the other extreme (any designer getting anything built, truly one-off / one-customer cars).

I think LocalMotors falls at a great spot along the spectrum. Many people can design, many people can vote and choose what they want, and some number of designs (remains to be seen) get made.

As a non-designer, I totally dig it.

Crisp Angles said...

Advancement in any design field is the introduction of new, fresh ideas.

When an optimistically minded architect known as Frank Lloyd Wright started to challenge conventional building technique with his controversial designs, creative engineers overcame the obstacles by creating new solutions. When the revolutionary Bangle-Hooydonk era arrived, the design world was turned upside down. Consumers actually went out of their way to recruit as many signatures as possible to oust the daring design chief. Now, we see every car company taking cues from those "bangled 7's." Even Mercedes Benz- the company that invented the automobile- is following in their wake. New designs that push us out of our comfort zone- usually at first glance will make us uncomfortable- but in the long run, will ultimately be incorporated into the design vocabulary by future designers. However, people in general are sheep- they are comfortable with what they know, and will generally follow the herd.

I do believe that there is a chance for Local Motors to accomplish something- the degree of revolution has yet to be determined.

Design Democracy?

Design democracy is an interesting concept that I've been pondering for years now. One one hand, public opinion results are always skewed -the accurate representation of public opinion is compromised by a number of factors, ie.. anyone willing to register 50 different email addresses, and subsequently, votes in their favor. At worst- it becomes a popularity contest. There needs to be a final say- such as in the judicial system, where the jury votes, then the Judge makes the final decision. On the other hand, the idea that "by letting everyone voice their opinion, fresh ideas may come about as a result" can not be refuted.

Design vs Art

What's the difference between design and art? Those two words seem to be inextricably combined when it comes to the design field. To answer this, I studied under Tom Matano for six years- and when I finally found the answer, it shocked me.

Design is a pragmatic solution to a problem that either does or doesn't exist yet. This is often misconstrued with the passionate regurgitation of existing designs- artistic, self-expression- the antithesis of a pragmatic solution. The majority of transportation design students will eventually make the transition from the the latter to the first- and once the concept is understood, their self-expression will be marketable.

In the end, is this democratic car company stagnating or advancing design? I feel it has the capacity to do both. In my earlier blogging, I mentioned that "by aiming for design democracy, I feel that Local Motors is not actually advancing design, but rather stagnating it a bit by giving power to the people." By this statement, I do not mean they're killing design, I simply mean the advancement may not be as advanced as many hope, if the power to decide is given to the everyman.

Fangyaya said...

polo shirts
tods outlet store
gucci handbags
mont blanc pens outlet
michael kors outlet
true religion outlet
nike roshe one
fitflop sandals
oakley sunglasses wholesale
coach factory outlet online
jordan shoes
beats by dre
polo outlet
tory burch flats
ghd flat iron
christian louboutin sale
ralph lauren
polo ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet online
true religion outlet online
louis vuitton purses
cheap jordan shoes
cheap air jordans
montblanc pens
kobe 11 shoes
adidas yeezy
louis vuitton outlet
the north face jackets
toms shoes
basketball shoes
coach outlet store
cheap ray ban sunglasses
vans outlet
coach factory outlet
cheap toms
louis vuitton outlet stores
pandora jewelry
christian louboutin outlet
michael kors outlet
fitflop sale
20168.6chenjinyan

dada24 Xu said...

polo ralph lauren men
ray ban sunglasses outlet
michael kors outlet online
ed hardy
coach factory outlet
ugg boots canada
ugg boots canada
kate spade uk
nike free flyknit 3.0
coach factory outlet online
nike air max 90
cheap jordan shoes
lacoste shoes
ugg boots outlet
longchamp bags
louis vuitton handbags
cheap ray ban sunglasses
true religion outlet store
uggs outlet
coach outlet online
nike trainers
uggs outlet
fitflops
coach outlet online
oakley sunglasses cheap
air jordan shoes
coach outlet store online clearance
uggs
michael kors outlet online
polo ralph lauren
designer handbags wholesale
ugg outlet online
chaussure louboutin
2016818caiyan

dada24 Xu said...

ray ban sunglasses
yeezy 350 boost
true religion
burberry outlet
michael kors canada
christian louboutin outlet
red bottoms shoes
canada goose jackets
true religion jeans
jerseys wholesale
2061927caiyan

muh wahid said...

Ai-wahed
Al-ahmar
Al-asfan
Al-ashab
Al-fadee
Al-fahl
Al-hadiye
Al-sham
Adib

Syaniezt Barbie said...

The Article is very interesting and I like it. Harga Fiforlif di Surabaya kota , Jual Fiforlif di Surabaya kota , Agen fiforlif di Surabaya kota , Manfaat Fiforlif , Distributor Fiforlif di Surabaya kota

Syaniezt Barbie said...

The Article is very interesting and I like it. Agen jual fiforlif Balikpapan , Harga Fiforlif di Balikpapan , Jual Fiforlif Murah di Balikpapan , Manfaat Fiforlif , Distributor Fiforlif di Balikpapan

Dwi satriyo said...

The Article is very interesting and I like it. Harga Fiforlif di Semarang , Jual Fiforlif di Semarang , Agen fiforlif di Semarang , Manfaat Fiforlif , Distributor Fiforlif di Semarang

Dang Dang Dut said...

Nice Information, thank you for sharing this knowledge

Download aplikasi digital info pendidikan informasi beasiswa s2 jadwal pendaftaran sbmptn game tebak gambar android akreditasi universitas terbuka informasi pendaftaran kuliah